3 Undervalued Dividend-Paying Insurance Stocks

Published Wed, 16 Sep 2015 09:30 by DividendYields.org

The most important determinant of a stock’s return is the price investors pay for it. There are globally-known companies with good quality and management, yet their stock prices do not reflect their growth potential and/or competitive position. It is also essential to understand that some companies are riskier than others and therefore a larger margin of safety is required to invest in them. The Graham number measures the fundamental value of a stock by taking into account earning per share (EPS) and book value per share (BVPS) and indicates the highest price a defensive investor would pay for the stock. Any stock price below the Graham number is considered undervalued, thus leaving room for higher return on investment. The formula for the Graham Number = SQRT (22.5 x EPS x BVPS).
The article discusses 3 mid-cap property & casualty insurance companies, which, according to the Graham number, are undervalued and pay dividends at a steady rate.

American Financial, CNA Financial and Cincinnati Financial Stock Performance Year over Year Graph
American Financial Group (NYSE: AFG) is a Cincinnati-based property and casualty insurance holding company that provides specialized commercial insurance products as well as fixed and fixed-indexed annuities through Great American Insurance Group to retailers and businesses both in the U.S. and internationally. In Q2 2015, AFG reported 47% YoY growth in dividends and repurchases of common stock ($122 million from $83 million in Q2 2014), whereas AFG’s excess capital grew by 2.6%, reaching $1.18 billion from $1.15 billion in the same quarter last year. Currently, AFG trades at a discount to fair value rate of 93.3%, suggesting that the stock is slightly undervalued. Considering the low Debt/Equity ratio, well below 2, low payout ratio and a beta of 0.81, AFG is a safe undervalued stock that delivers dividends at a steady rate. Analyst consensus estimates an average annual rate of 8% for the next five years, and an average EPS of $5.58 up to 2016, allowing an adequate margin of safety.

CNA Financial Corporation (NYSE: CNA) is one of the leading property and casualty insurance companies providing insurance protection services to retailers and businesses, including risk management and claim administration services, both in the U.S and internationally through its subsidiaries. Currently, CNA trades at a discount to fair value rate of 65.63%, suggesting that the stock is considerably undervalued. CAN’s reported Q2 2015 66.5% YoY growth in dividends ($676 million from $406 million in Q2 2014) as well as 135.7% YoY growth in equity securities ($33 million from $14 million in Q2 2014) are in line with consensus forecast for long-term 5-years growth of 7.5% annually and an average EPS of $3.15 up to 2016. Given the company’s low payout ratio and Graham number, CAN is definitely selling for a good price, leaving room for further growth.

Name Price ($) Market Cap ($ b) P/E EPS BVPS Graham Number Discount to Fair Value D/E Beta Payout Ratio
American Financial 69.39 6.08 15.50 4.48 54.85 74.36 93.3% 0.21 0.81 22%
CAN Financial 35.59 9.62 12.31 2.89 45.27 54.26 65.6% 0.21 1.32 35%
Cincinnati Financial 52.91 8.68 13.39 3.96 39.62 59.41 89.1% 0.13 0.93 47%

Cincinnati Financial Corporation (Nasdaq: CINF) is an Ohio based insurance holding company engaging in property and casualty insurance through a broad network of independent insurance and financial services subsidiaries across the U.S. Being in the top-25 property casualty insurer groups, the company provides a wide range of insurance products, including life insurance, disability income policies and fixed annuities. CINF revised its value creation ratio to range between 10% and 13% up to 2017, following the 33.9% YoY growth in cash flow from operating activities ($470 million from $351 million in Q2 2014). Given that the stock is fairly undervalued, trading at a discount to fair value rate of 89.1%, the value creation ratio suggests CINF’s ability to increase its book value and deliver higher dividends to its shareholders. Additionally, the company’s strategic decision to engage in mergers and acquisitions to deliver long-term shareholder value improves its growth potential, which is also reflected in an average EPS of $2.60 up to 2016.


Stock name Dividend Yield
Cincinnati Financial 2.59
Cna Financial 2.31
American Financial Group 1.22

Articles featuring Cincinnati Financial (CINF):

John And Jane: June Dividend Income Tracker - Taxable Account

Investment Thesis June marks the eighth month that John and Jane have been receiving consistent dividend income from their Taxable portfolio. June was a slower month for the Taxable portfolio in that only two companies paid increased dividends. As a reminder for readers, I continue to use this series to document John and Jane's success with the long-term goal of creating a database that can be used for monthly and year-over-year (YoY) comparisons that demonstrate to readers the power... Read more

10 Top 'Safer' Dividend Aristocrats Show 12.5-32.9% Gains Per July Audit

Actionable Conclusions (1-10): Brokers Project Top Ten 'Safer' Dividend Aristocrats Stocks to Net 14.66% to 38.2% Gains To July 2019 Four of the ten biggest yield "safer" Dividend Aristocrats (tinted in the chart above) showed up in the Top ten gainers for the coming year, based on analyst 1-year target prices. Thus the yield selection strategy for this group as graded by analyst estimates proved 40% accurate. Projections based on estimated dividend returns from $1000... Read more

Fix Your Roof While The Sun Is Shining: The Dividend Aristocrats Are (Sorta) On Sale

A large number of articles on Seeking Alpha are dedicated to dividend growth investing, and one finds no shortage of articles exhorting investors to consider the Dividend Aristocrats. To Seeking Alpha readers, these stocks need no introduction, but as regular contributor Ploutos reminds us in a recent overview, these are those select few companies (around 50 or so in number) that have increased their dividend payouts for 25 or more consecutive years. These stocks appeal for a variety of... Read more

Dividend Stock Analysis: Cincinnati Financial Corporation

This weekend, with a nice cup of coffee in hand, I started performing research to identify a new undervalued dividend growth stock to add to my portfolio. When I was using my stock screener, I noticed that there was one Dividend Aristocrat that was currently down 7.98% year-to-date. Obviously, that caught my attention. I thought it would be a great idea to perform a dividend stock analysis to determine if this company was currently undervalued and would pass the metrics of our Dividend Stock... Read more

John And Jane: May Dividend Income Tracker - Taxable Account

Investment Thesis May marks the seventh month that John and Jane have had a well-established concentration of stocks in their taxable portfolio. A total of seven stocks in the taxable portfolio delivered increased dividend payments during the month of May. As I continue to document John and Jane's success, my long-term goal is to create a database that allows for year-over-year (YoY) comparisons that demonstrate the power and simplicity of dividend investing. In addition to documenting... Read more